Meh... Or should I say arr...?
It was pretty good. It could have been better, obviously, a lot of things "could be better" and this is one of them. First off: stickfigures. I don't know why, and don't hate me because of it, but the stickfigure scenes just weren't very good to me. Another thing was the preloader game. It blew. Hard. And you didn't even have any peglegs.
On a more positive note, the music was awesome, the speedboats were cool, and the fact that this is a pirate collab were awesome. you get 8 stars from me, and a 4/5 on the actual votey-thingy.